Someone recently asked me this question – “Why are religious people so prone to conspiracy theories?”

It’s an excellent question.

And it’s definitely a scary trend I’ve been noticing myself since coming out of the fog of my own religious indoctrination experience.

I’m going to give you the short answer, and then we’ll unpack it further in this article..

Here’s the short answer:

In my opinion people who have experienced religious indoctrination are more susceptible to falling for conspiracy theories because the mind control of their religion has primed their brains to accept illogical concepts as reality.

But let’s dive into this a bit further.

Hierarchy of Authority

Religious folks who are more prone to conspiracy theories are often accustomed to a hierarchy of authority within their religious communities. 

In these groups, there exists a clear and rigid structure of leadership, where unquestioning obedience to religious authorities is emphasized. 

As a result, members may become more likely to accept conspiracy theories that align with the narratives promoted by those in positions of authority.

Preaching Politics from the Pulpit

I was emerging into adulthood during Obama’s first presidential candidacy, and this was the first election I would be old enough to vote in.

At the time, I was attending a baptist church where the pastor routinely pushed a political agenda from the pulpit.

During this time, he routinely attempted to draw connections between Obama and the “antichrist” and discussed how “end times were drawing nigh.”

I’m not sure if this could be classified as a conspiracy theory, but I think it’s a clear example of how religious leaders can use the bible and biblical prophecy to incite fear and push members into believing truly farcical things.

Thankfully I was already out of the church when some of the more recent conspiracy theories came around.

However, I know there are many culty religions that absolutely capitalize on current issues and events.

The Power of Influence

Keep in mind that within these hierarchies, religious leaders often wield considerable influence and hold the power to shape the worldview of their followers.

Under the guise of spiritual guidance, these leaders often exploit their followers’ trust and vulnerability, perpetuating narratives that align with their own biases or agendas.

People who are  accustomed to hierarchical authority may fear repercussions for questioning or challenging the prevailing beliefs, thereby silencing any dissenting voices within the community.

This fear-driven environment ultimately creates a culture of conformity, where adhering to the group’s beliefs, no matter how unfounded or irrational, becomes a priority to maintain social acceptance and avoid potential ostracism.

Black & White Thinking

Black and white thinking is a cognitive distortion that plays a significant role in making members of high control religions more vulnerable to accepting conspiracy theories.

Within these religious communities, beliefs are often presented as absolute truths with no room for ambiguity or shades of gray.

This cognitive rigidity reinforces a worldview where events and ideas are perceived as either completely right or entirely wrong, leaving little space for critical evaluation or skepticism.

A Space for Conspiracy Theories to Thrive

Conspiracy theories thrive in environments where nuance and complexity are disregarded in favor of oversimplified narratives.

The allure of conspiracy theories lies in their ability to provide clear-cut explanations for complex phenomena and a sense of order in seemingly chaotic situations.

For religious folks accustomed to black and white thinking, these theories offer a sense of certainty and stability, even when facing uncertainties and crises.

This is big part of the reason why there were a couple conspiracy theories that were wildly successful over the past several years.

Only the Group Can Be Trusted

In the context of authoritarian religions, black and white thinking often extends to viewing the group’s beliefs as the ultimate truth, while dismissing any alternative perspectives as misguided or malevolent.

This absolutist mindset fosters an “us versus them” mentality.

Within this mentality, those within the group are seen as righteous and virtuous, while those outside are demonized or perceived as threats to the group’s identity and integrity.

This creates an echo chamber where only the group is deemed trustworthy and all external information is rejected or distorted.

Conspiracy theories are often used to validate and reinforce these beliefs, further strengthening the group’s cohesion and insulation from outside influences.

Encouraging Polarization

Moreover, black and white thinking can lead to the polarization of information sources.

Christians in these groups may be more inclined to consume and trust information from sources that align with their pre-existing beliefs, while dismissing or outright rejecting sources that challenge or contradict their views.

{FYI: information control is a glaring red flag of a religious cult.}

This selective exposure to information reinforces their existing beliefs and shields them from alternative viewpoints, further entrenching them in their conspiratorial beliefs.

This can also lead to a denial of facts and evidence, as conflicting information is dismissed or rationalized away.

Conspiracy theories not only polarize individuals within the group, but also contribute to the polarization of society as a whole, which we’ve definitely seen as a trend in recent years.

Suspension of Reality

Suspension of reality involves a willingness to accept and believe in ideas, narratives, or conspiracy theories that may lack substantial evidence or contradict objective reality.

If you think about it, many religious folks have had to do this from the very beginning of their “conversion experience” since the majority of beliefs found within high control religions are based on logical fallacies.

The Prevalence of Logical Fallacies

The prevalence of logical fallacies among many religious groups, particularly authoritarian groups, make many members much more prone to accepting conspiracy theories.

Logical fallacies are errors in reasoning that can lead to flawed or unsound arguments, and they can undermine critical thinking and rational decision-making.

When these fallacies become ingrained in a person’s belief system, they can create cognitive vulnerabilities that contribute to the acceptance of conspiracy theories.

Required Belief in the Supernatural

Because many high control religions are predicated on the belief in supernatural forces, members of these groups are often more open to extraordinary or unverifiable claims.

In fact, they are praised for having “faith in things unseen” while rebuked for having doubts.

Concepts such as miracles, divine intervention, and the afterlife are central to Christian theology and are viewed as literal experiences among fundamentalist Christian groups.

This belief in the miraculous and the transcendent can create a mindset where accepting other extraordinary or unsubstantiated claims becomes more plausible.

Suppression of Critical Thought

The suppression of critical thought among many Christian communities can contribute significantly to the acceptance of conspiracy theories.

When critical thinking is discouraged or actively stifled, it creates an environment where people tend to be less likely to question or scrutinize the information they encounter.

Rejection of Skepticism

Critical thinking involves healthy skepticism and a willingness to question ideas and claims.

When skepticism is seen as a lack of faith or disobedience, religious folks may suppress their doubts and refrain from asking challenging questions.

As a result, conspiracy theories that challenge mainstream narratives can be embraced without examining the evidence or critically evaluating their plausibility.

In fact, many high control religious groups actively reject science and evidence-based thinking, making it easier for conspiracy theories to take hold.

Censorship of Dissenting Views

Suppression of critical thought often involves censoring or discouraging dissenting views within the community.

This creates an echo chamber where alternative perspectives or evidence contrary to the prevailing beliefs are not allowed or dismissed outright.

Without exposure to diverse viewpoints, religious folks remain insulated from counterarguments.

And this insulation means they are now much more susceptible to being swayed by conspiracy theories presented within their closed information bubble.

Vulnerability to Manipulation

The suppression of critical thought can also make individuals more susceptible to manipulation and control by religious leaders.

When people are discouraged from questioning authority or thinking critically, they are more likely to blindly follow the beliefs and directives of their leaders.

This makes them vulnerable to being manipulated into believing conspiracy theories that align with the leaders’ agendas.

Moreover, when critical thinking is discouraged, people indoctrinated into a high control group may struggle to critically evaluate the claims and evidence presented by these leaders.

This can lead to blind acceptance of conspiracy theories without proper scrutiny.

Appeal to Emotion Over Reason 

Conspiracy theories often rely on emotional appeals, playing on people’s fear, anger, or a sense of injustice.

When critical thinking is suppressed, folks may be more susceptible to emotional manipulation, making it easier for conspiracy theories to resonate on an emotional level, regardless of their lack of factual basis.

This one was particularly significant for me during my time in Evangelical Christianity because the group often preyed on my empathetic nature in order to shape my beliefs and behaviors.

Since conspiracy theories are often built on a predator/victim mentality, religious folks will dive head first into defending/saving a “victim” from a perceived predator without taking time to examine the narrative.

Disclaimer: There are absolutely real victims and real predators in our world and atrocities which need to be brought to an end. However, it is important to carefully examine religiously-motivated victim/predator narratives.

Final Thoughts

Religious folks are not more prone to accepting conspiracy theories because they lack intelligence.

They are more prone to accepting conspiracy theories because they have been systematically groomed by their religious group to:

• unquestioningly accept the teachings of those in authority
• participate in black & white thinking
• suspend reality
• suppress critical thinking

When people begin to recover from the mind control prevalent among many religious groups, they are less likely to accept conspiracy theories because most of these theories don’t stand up to critical scrutiny.

What To Do Next

We covered quite a bit of information in this article.

If you’re wondering what to do next, consider the following…

Join the Group

One thing I would definitely encourage you to do is to check out my private Facebook group for folks recovering from religious harm:

• The Religious Harm Recovery Group

Check Out These Article

• What is a High Control Religion?
• Two Insidious Ways Religious Cults Use Your Emotions Against You
• What You Need to Know About Phobia Indoctrination & Religious Cults

Stay Connected

Most importantly you’ll want to make sure you’re on my email list.

Every Thursday I send out a topical email related to religious indoctrination and religious harm recovery.

Use the form below to sign up!